March 2006 --- Six
months ago Chris Carmichael, a Christian satirist, would have never
believed that one day he would be reduced to standing on a busy
intersection in Kansas City, MO, holding a sign that reads, “Will
Mock for Food.” But this is the situation now that Carmichael is no
longer able to make a decent living lampooning postmodern
Christianity. Out of work and destitute, Carmichael now grovels for
enough money to buy himself a Egg McMuffin for his
only meal of the day. “Just last fall I was still able to target
some of the unbiblical activities of certain Christian organizations
and take their absurdity to a satirical extreme to expose their
folly,” laments Carmichael, “but now these organizations have
gone to the ultimate level of absurdity all by themselves. I can’t
compete with that.”
A twenty year veteran of the Christian humor business,
Carmichael was at the height of his game when suddenly the line
between satire and reality began to blur this last year. The pivotal
moment came when Carmichael mocked up a fake “Biblezine for Girls”
and everyone thought it was real. Said Carmichael, “It had Britney
Spear’s photo on the cover with the headline: ‘Hit Me, Jesus, One
More Time: Finding God’s Truth in Pop Song Lyrics‘. I knew I was in
trouble when Christianity Today thought I was submitting an ad from Family
Christian bookstore. Worse yet, Zondervan wanted to sue me for
stealing the cover idea for their upcoming ‘Hey, Girlfriend!’ Bible.
How was I supposed to know?”
Carmichael is only one in a growing number of
Christian satirists who is finding it difficult to practice their
craft in the current atmosphere of the worldly pragmatic
philosophy that permeates the postmodern Church. Blaine Davies, a
freelance humorist who created the now-classic “Bible study at
Hooters” satire, was devastated when a church ministry actually
started a Bible group at Hooters, thus eliminating the cutting-edge
wit of his original piece. “Their irresponsible actions virtually
removed any hope of me selling the reprint rights to that parody,”
Davies confided. “Thank goodness I’m still able to market my latest
parody about a Christian outreach ministry that goes to strip clubs
so they can preach the gospel to the strippers who are giving them
lap dances.” When informed that there was already a Christian
ministry doing something like
that, Davies buried his head in his hands
and sobbed uncontrollably. Like Job stripped of his dignity, Davies
had come face-to-face with the bleakness of his situation which no
two-ply Kleenex could relieve.
Because of situations like the one facing Davies, evangelical satirists like
Chris Carmichael have been forced to look elsewhere for employment,
without much success. “Oh, I’ve knocked on the Wittenburg Door, but
they wouldn't open it,” explained Carmichael. “And Lark News? They
wouldn't hire me unless I took payment in Lark News T-shirts.
Apparently they can't give those things away.” For a time,
Carmichael was so desperate for work that he did something of which
he is not proud: writing opening jokes for Joel Osteen sermons.
“I felt so cheap,” Carmichael winced. “It’s amazing how easy you can
resort to peddling lame jokes just to keep the heat on in your
apartment.”
Nowadays, Carmichael doesn’t even have the apartment
anymore. Instead, he lives in a cardboard box under the Paseo Bridge
which he shares with a small group of other impoverished Christian
satirists who have struggled to find work. This rag-tag gang of
inspired wits often gathers around a
barrel fire in the evenings and talks about the good old days.
“Those were heady times back when a fella could count on Jim and
Tammy Faye Bakker for material,” remembered Carmichael. “But things
are different now that churches have started ripping off our ideas.
We aren't just competing with Saturday Night Live these days, now we
have to battle with Sunday Morning Live, too.”
While Carmichael remains resolute in his
determination to get through these bad times, other starving
satirists have buckled under the pressure and done the unthinkable,
admits Carmichael. "A few of my colleagues gave up the fight and
found work as pastors in Emergent churches. But
at least they get paid for doing what they love: making up stuff to amuse
folks."
All is not lost in the world of evangelical
absurdity, however. One Christian humorist,
who hasn’t yet become homeless, has vowed to fight the trend that is
making Christian satire obsolete. Denny Kuckelman believes he has
found the answer to stopping Christians from
being tempted to push the envelope of worldly pragmatism. Explained Kuckelman
with a smile, “Now when I parody a new Christian philosophy or
activity, I have my lawyer register a copyright on my idea. So if a
Catholic church wants to put in a Drive-Thru Confessional®,
they can go right ahead. But they will have to pay me big bucks to
get the rights to do it. Hey, if Rick Warren can trademark his crazy
ideas, so can I.”